Are Solar Panels Bad For The Environment

Chemicals In The Solar Manufacturing Process: Are They Dangerous

The primary material used for solar cells today is silicon, which is derived from quartz. In order to become usable forms of silicon, the quartz has to be mined and heated in a furnace .

There are some chemicals used in the manufacturing process to prepare silicon and make the wafers for monocrystalline and polycrystalline panels. One of the most toxic chemicals created as a byproduct of this process is silicon tetrachloride. This chemical, if not handled and disposed of properly, can lead to burns on your skin, harmful air pollutants that increase lung disease, and if exposed to water can release hydrochloric acid, which is a corrosive substance bad for human and environmental health. Fortunately, there is a process that most manufacturers employ to safely recycle silicon tetrachloride back into the manufacturing process for new silicon wafers, helping to eliminate health and environmental risks.

The large majority of panels used in installations are safe, silicon-based panels however, if youre installing thin-film technology, there are additional toxic materials contained in the thin-film panels itself, such as cadmium telluride and copper indium selenide. These materials are used in the manufacturing process for many other electronics, like your cell phone or laptop. Thin-film panels are not common for residential solar installations and are most often used in large commercial or utility scaled applications.

Can The Radiation From Solar Panels Increase Cancer Risk

Electric and magnetic fields together are called electromagnetic fields, or electromagnetic radiation. Imagine these electromagnetic fields on a spectrum, with low-frequency radiation on the low end, which includes things like power lines, and high-frequency radiation on the high end, which includes things like x-rays. Low-frequency radiation is less harmful than high-frequency radiation, which can damage DNA and cells.

Electricity from solar panels and transmission to the power grid emits extremely weak electromagnetic fields. Exposure to low-level electromagnetic fields has been studied extensively, and there is no evidence that it is harmful to human health, according to the World Health Organization . In fact, the WHO notes that most scientists and doctors agree that if any health effects exist from low-level electromagnetic fields, they are likely to be very small compared to other health risks that people face in daily life.

Other agencies, like the European Commission Scientific Committee on Emerging and Newly Identifiable Health Risks, take a more cautious stance. They say that its possible, but far from conclusive, that extremely low-frequency magnetic fields could be carcinogenic, or have the potential to cause cancer, according to a 2015 report. In the same report, the committee notes that studies of magnetic fields generated by roof-mounted solar panels are scarce and that no conclusions can be drawn.

Reasons Solar Panels Are Good For The Environment

Its true that there are reasons for saying that solar panels are bad for the environment. But this needs to be offset against the ways in which they are good for the environment. One of these is that they provide sustainable energy.

Solar panels are also an affordable source of renewable energy for many homeowners. Although there is an initial cost, these costs have fallen by nearly 70% in the last 7 years. There are also federal and state tax breaks that make them more affordable.

Other advantages of solar energy include the fact that once in place it produces no pollutants. No carbon emissions mean that you are reducing your carbon footprint.

Read Also: How To Get A Job In Solar Energy

What Exactly Is Renewable Energy

Renewable energy is energy from naturally replenishing but flow-limited sources Renewable resources are virtually inexhaustible in the long run but limited in the amount of energy that is available per unit time. The main types of renewable energy sources are: Biomass. Wood and wood waste.

What is renewable in simple words?

Definition of renewables 1: capable of renewing renewable contracts. 2: able to be replaced by natural ecological cycles or renewable resources of good management practices.

Who Would Pay For Clean Up If A Solar Farm Was Damaged

Solar panels are more durable than they might look. Though made of glass, they are constructed to withstand harsh weather elements and frequently live up to the challenge.

When affixed to a home, solar panels are capable of withstanding windspeeds of over 140-160 miles per hour, similar to the strength of category 4 and 5 storms, reported UN-accredited non-profit Ideas For Us. Some panels are built to withstand even stronger wind strengths.

In Denver, Colorado, a hailstorm that punched holes in roofs and cars damaged just a single panel in a 3,000-panel project. This track record isnt limited to just rooftop panels, either. During Hurricane Florence, North Carolinas utility-scale solar farm network went virtually unscathed.

Its not impossible for panels to break, though, and in that case, who is responsible for fixing it?

Examples are scarce, but it appears it is the responsibility of the farm owner to clean up the mess. When Hurricane Maria took out a good portion of the Humacao solar facility in Puerto Rico, the managing utility company hired a solar developer to fix it. In the case of rooftop solar, the system warranty should cover the repair.

As for any toxic leaks as a result of broken panels, the chain of command is unclear. The need for it, however, is also unlikely. The bottom line: Solar panels are strong enough to withstand the elements and rarely face damage.

/ Shutterstock

Recommended Reading: Can A Sole Proprietor Build Business Credit

Solar Panel Carbon Print

Greenhouse gas emission is responsible for over 72 grams of carbon dioxide, which is equivalent to a kWh of electricity generated.

Any solar power plant also has an average environmental footprint of about 20gm of CO2 for every kilowatt-hour of electricity generated on top of consuming large water amounts. This is way low than the carbon print effect by regular electricity production.

During the production of solar panels, manufacturers handle toxic chemicals. However, once the panels are complete, they emit no toxins into the atmosphere.

Dont Miss: What Is The Cost Of Solar Panels For A House

Is The Solar Industry Improving

One of the most promising new solar energy technologies in development uses a material called perovskite. The structure of these crystals makes them very effective at absorbing sunlight. Its also better at absorbing indoors and on overcast days than silicon. Thin films made from perovskite can even be painted on buildings.

Image credit: U.S. Department of Energy

More efficient cell design now has an almost 75% market share. While even higher-efficiency designs expanded in commercial production and captured about 20% of the market in 2021.

The solar PV industry could create 1300 manufacturing jobs for each gigawatt of production capacity. New manufacturing facilities could attract 120 billion USD investment by 2030.

A solar photovoltaic installer is predicted to be one of the fastest-growing occupations in the US from 2021-2031.

Since 2011, continuous innovation by China has halved the intensity of solar PV manufacturing emissions.

Chinas 2022 Five-Year Plan stated that 33% of electricity generation is to come from renewables by 2025 . This includes an 18% target for wind and solar power.

In August 2022, the US introduced the Inflation Reduction Acta law that significantly expands support over the next 10 years for renewable energy through tax credits and other measures.

Image credit: Statista

Solar power system grids need to be modified to be more flexible over time and integrate larger amounts to ensure theyre able to handle variability in demand.

You May Like: What’s Bad About Solar Energy

This Story Is Part Of A Group Of Stories Called

The biodiversity crisis, explained

Help our biodiversity reporting by taking our survey.

Every several years sometimes just once a decade when the rains come in just the right amounts and at just the right times, rare flowers speckle the Mojave Desert in California. Some, like the Barstow woolly sunflower, emerge from plants no larger than a thumbnail. They spring forth from seeds that have persisted in the dry soil for years, waiting for just such a sporadic event.

In these brief super-blooms, the desert floor looks like a carpet of wildflowers unfurled across the landscape, said Karen Tanner, a researcher at University of California, Santa Cruz. The quick flash of flora helps replenish the seeds for future generations.

At other times, large sections of this deceptively fragile ecosystem look like the moon, Tanner said. Which, under the punishing sun, makes it seem like an ideal place to build large solar installations. Swaths of the desert, which spans four states, have already been converted to solar facilities, and more are on the way in the Mojave and across the US. More than 4,600 square miles of land is projected to be covered by solar installations by 2030.

One thing is clear to her: Its just not enough to do one survey in one year and be like, Oh yeah, theres nothing here. Go ahead and install the infrastructure, she said.

Impacts To Soil Water And Air Resources

The construction of solar facilities on vast areas of land imposes clearing and grading, resulting in soil compaction, alteration of drainage channels and increased erosion. Central tower systems require consuming water for cooling, which is a concern in arid settings, as an increase in water demand may strain available water resources as well as chemical spills from the facilities which may result in the contamination of groundwater or the ground surface.

As with the development of any large-scale industrial facility, the construction of solar energy power plants can pose hazards to air quality. Such threats include the release of soil-carried pathogens and results in an increase in air particulate matter which has the effect of contaminating water reservoirs.

You May Like: Does Pine Sol Deter Mice

The Problem With Solar Panel Disposal

Most solar recycling plants simply remove the valuable silver and copper from the cells and then recycle the contaminated glass and plastic casing by burning them in cement ovens. Since the process is costly and time-consuming, its more convenient for solar companies to drop the dead panels into landfills or export them to third-world countries.

While a properly-built landfill should contain most hazardous material in the waste, a developing country may not have the infrastructure or regulations to properly dispose of imported solar panel waste. Potential leaching of these metals into the surrounding environment can pose a public health problem, especially in a nation without the necessary disposal infrastructure. As society continues to adopt solar power, this problem may worsen in the coming decades, with almost 80 million tons of solar waste projected by 2050.

Studies have shown the heavy metals in solar panels namely lead and cadmium can leach out of the cells and get into groundwater, as well as affect plants. These metals also have a record for detrimental effects on human health. Lead is commonly known to impair brain development in children, and cadmium is a carcinogen.

Whats Bad About Solar Energy

The two main disadvantages of solar energy are: they generate little energy when the weather is poor. they do not produce any power at night and batteries are required.

Is something wrong with solar power? However, some toxic and chemical materials are used to make photovoltaic cells that convert sunlight into electricity. Some solar thermal systems use potentially hazardous fluids to transfer heat. Leaks of these materials can be harmful to the environment.

You May Like: Does Granite Come In Solid Colors

Are Solar Panels Good For The Environment

Solar is a clean energy source with tons of environmental benefits. When photovoltaic panels generate electricity, they offset carbon dioxide emissions with renewable energy.

But have you ever thought about how solar panels are made and disposed of, and the environmental effects of these processes?

Energys carbon footprint is a balancing act. Most of us have this idea that solar, wind, and hydropower are guilt-free sources. But thats not quite the whole story.

Even green energy comes at a cost. So, lets figure out the solar industrys impact on the planet and whether theyre as environmentally friendly as were told.

Who Pays The Bill

It will almost certainly fall to regulators to decide who will bear the cleanup costs. As waste from the first wave of early replacements piles up in the next few years, the U.S. government starting with the states, but surely escalating to the federal level will introduce solar panel recycling legislation. Conceivably, future regulations in the U.S. will follow the model of the European Unions WEEE Directive, a legal framework for the recycling and disposal of electronic waste throughout EU member states. The U.S. states that have enacted electronics-recycling legislation have mostly cleaved to the WEEE model. In the EU, recycling responsibilities for past waste have been apportioned to manufacturers based on current market share.

A first step to forestalling disaster may be for solar panel producers to start lobbying for similar legislation in the United States immediately, instead of waiting for solar panels to start clogging landfills. In our experience drafting and implementing the revision of the original WEEE Directive in the late 2000s, we found one of the biggest challenges in those early years was assigning responsibility for the vast amount of accumulated waste generated by companies no longer in the electronics business .

Read Also: Solar Charger For Car Battery

Land Use And Ecological Impacts

In the point of generating electricity at a utility-scale, solar energy facilities necessitate large areas for collection of energy. Due to this, the facilities may interfere with existing land uses and can impact the use of areas such as wilderness or recreational management areas.

As energy systems may impact land through materials exploration, extraction, manufacturing and disposal, energy footprints can become incrementally high. Thus, some of the lands may be utilised for energy in such a way that returning to a pre-disturbed state necessitates significant energy input or time, or both, whereas other uses are so dramatic that incurred changes are irreversible.

Create An Account To Access More Content And Features On Ieee Spectrum Including The Ability To Save Articles To Read Later Download Spectrum Collections And Participate In Conversations With Readers And Editors For More Exclusive Content And Features Consider Joining Ieee

Solar panels glimmering in the sun are an icon of all that is green. But while generating electricity through photovoltaics is indeed better for the environment than burning fossil fuels, several incidents have linked the manufacture of these shining symbols of environmental virtue to a trail of chemical pollution. And it turns out that the time it takes to compensate for the energy used and the greenhouse gases emitted in photovoltaic panel production varies substantially by technology and geography.

Thats the bad news. The good news is that the industry could readily eliminate many of the damaging side effects that do exist. Indeed, pressure for it to do so is mounting, in part because, since 2008, has moved from Europe, Japan, and the United States to China, Malaysia, the Philippines, and Taiwan today nearly half the worlds photovoltaics are manufactured in China. As a result, although the overall track record for the industry is good, the countries that produce the most photovoltaics today typically do the worst job of protecting the environment and their workers.

Acid Drain:

The papers investigation, , profiled a Chinese polysilicon facility owned by Luoyang Zhonggui High-Technology Co., located near the Yellow River in the countrys Henan province. This facility supplied polysilicon to Suntech Power Holdings, at the time the worlds largest solar-cell manufacturer, as well as to several other high-profile photovoltaics companies.

Carbon in Creation:

You May Like: How Does A Solar Battery Charger Work

Are Solar Panel Fields Bad For The Environment The Facts

Solar Panel Fields can be bad for the environment if they are built in highly sensitive areas, including bird migration routs and coastal areas. However, when constructed in the right area, solar panel fields can be good for the environment because they produce clean energy that is used to provide power to our homes and cars.

Solar panels are made from rare earth materials and use toxic chemicals in their manufacture, but the majority of these are recyclable and pose little if any risk to humans or wildlife unless improperly disposed of. There will always be some risk from anything manufactured, but solar panels have very little emissions while in use.

Is Solar Energy Good Or Bad

Don’t Miss: How Much Does It Cost For Solar Panels

Pollutants And Solar Waste

The issue of recycling old photovoltaic panels has not received much attention, as the first few sets of panels installed are just now beginning to expire. Now that this expiration is upon us, the management of expired photovoltaic panels is becoming a pressing issue.

Solar panels are predominantly made out of glass but contain Cadmium and Lead, which are classified as carcinogenic. Because of this, there are safety concerns regarding impurities. To recycle these components, additional costs must be allocated to remove impurities.

Currently, since old photovoltaic panels cannot be conveniently recycled, they are commonly discharged in landfills. This process poses serious environmental risks because of the toxic chemicals found in the panels. Cadmium can be released and washed out with rainwater, which ends up leaching into the soil and polluting the surrounding area.